Category: Uncategorized

  • Interview: CSG’s Shadow Deals and Broken Promises

    Interview: CSG’s Shadow Deals and Broken Promises

    Source: https://www.seznamzpravy.cz/clanek/domaci-kauzy-ztrata-duvery-skryty-spoluvlastnik-popisuje-proc-chce-vykoupeni-z-csg-302047

    “Loss of Trust.” A silent partner explains why he wants to buy out of CSG

    Petr Kratochvíl is a major shareholder in two key companies within the CSG Group. The majority owner, Michal Strnad, reportedly offered him “a maximum of four billion” for his shares. Kratochvíl is now demanding much more.

    It was a major listing for the Czech company on the Amsterdam Stock Exchange. However, upon closer inspection, it turned out that the story of CSG—which major investment firms had valued at roughly 25 billion euros—had some flaws. When it went public, CSG failed to explicitly state that it also had significant minority shareholders within the group. Moreover, it had come into conflict with the most prominent one. He wants to sell his shares and is asking for tens of billions of crowns for them.

    His name is Petr Kratochvíl, he has spent virtually his entire life in the arms industry, and he was there at the birth of the Czechoslovak Group (CSG) as it exists today. In the months leading up to CSG’s IPO, he became embroiled in a major conflict with majority owner Michal Strnad, who took over CSG from his father.

    The situation came to a head just before the IPO; according to Kratochvíl, Michal Strnad told minority shareholders that he would not, in fact, list the holding company’s shares on the capital market. “Until the very last moment, he insisted to me that he wouldn’t go public. He offered me a price for my shares that I considered ridiculous. But I didn’t believe him about the IPO, so I kept my shares,” Petr Kratochvíl describes in an interview with Seznam Zprávy.

    His position is strong. He holds stakes in the most profitable parts of CSG, which account for the vast majority of the group’s total revenue. Specifically, these include a 10% stake in CSG Land Systems and an 8.9% stake in MSM Group.

    Why are you leaving CSG now?

    I have been with the group for more than 20 years and was involved in building its key divisions. That made the decision to leave all the more difficult for me. I am leaving CSG due to a loss of trust in the management and the majority shareholder.

    Where does this loss of trust stem from?

    During 2025, the majority shareholder offered to buy out my 10% stake in the Czech division of CSG LS and my 8.9% stake in the Slovak division of MSM Group for, and I quote, “a maximum of four billion crowns.” Naturally, I did not agree to this price.

    I have the right to a buyout based on market value as determined by an expert appraisal. I was also constantly assured by CSG representatives that there would be no IPO (the company’s listing on the stock exchange, ed.).

    Can you explain your position as a shareholder with special rights?

    I view the shareholder’s special rights as above-standard rights that go beyond the scope of the law and confirm not only my long-term involvement in the group but also the role I played in building its key components. These rights include, for example, the ability to participate in the appointment of statutory bodies through the so-called nomination right, approval of key changes in the company such as amendments to the articles of association, changes to the amount of share capital, changes to the capital structure, or the reorganization of a division, as well as economic rights such as a guaranteed dividend or a right of first refusal regarding the entire division, and so on.

    Did you exercise the put option (the majority shareholder must buy back the stake under predetermined conditions, ed.) at CSG Land Systems? When did you inform the group about this? And what price did your valuation set?

    Given that this information is already public knowledge, I can confirm that I exercised the put option on January 20, 2026. The value of the stake was determined by an expert appraisal at approximately 34 billion crowns, using a combination of standard valuation methods, DCF, and market comparison.

    Do you plan to exercise your option at MSM Group as well?

    Given the deep rifts between myself and the majority shareholder, as well as fundamental disagreements regarding the future direction of the divisions, I consider it logical and in everyone’s best interest for my departure to take place as soon as possible. I do not yet have an expert valuation report available. I have also communicated to CSG that I am prepared to negotiate my departure, including the MSM Group division. However, the response was that the majority shareholder does not consider personal negotiations to be expedient at this stage.

    Can you comment on the fact that the above was not included in the prospectus prior to the group’s entry into the capital market?

    Senior representatives of CSG are responsible for the content of the prospectus. Given that I hold an equity stake in divisions that account for more than 70 percent of the IPO’s value, I would expect the prospectus to transparently address aspects related to minority shareholders’ rights, particularly if they could impact cash flow, for example.

    From an investor’s perspective, I consider it standard practice to include, in such a case, qualified estimates of potential costs associated with, for example, the exercise of a put option.

  • Dangerous ties between CSG and its owner Michal Strnad to Russia

    Dangerous ties between CSG and its owner Michal Strnad to Russia

    Source: https://www.e15.cz/volby/volby-v-usa/vidlak-ktery-nema-rad-ukrajinu-a-strnadovu-csg-kdo-je-trumpuv-novy-viceprezident-vance-1417243

    US presidential candidate Donald Trump at the ongoing Republican convention has finally revealed his choice for vice president, the person who must be prepared to immediately take over if the head of state is unable to perform his duties. It will be Ohio Senator James David Vance, a man with a reputation as controversial as Trump’s

    According to the website Politico, this is bad news for Europe, as it increases the chances that a Republican administration, if victorious in the November elections, will halt military aid to Ukraine.

    A native of the small American town of Middletown, Ohio, he would become one of the youngest and least experienced vice presidents in US history if Trump defeats Joe Biden in the election. At 39, he is exactly half the age of his boss and only entered high politics less than two years ago.

    Unlike Trump, who comes from a wealthy business family, he grew up in a poor working-class environment. Vance’s mother was a drug addict, and his father abandoned him when James David was still a toddler. As a result, he was mostly cared for by his grandparents during his childhood. Nevertheless, he managed to work his way up to a successful career. He studied law at the prestigious Yale University, served in the military in Iraq, and later began working in Silicon Valley for companies involved in venture capital investments in startups.

    J. D. Vance first attracted significant media attention in 2016 when he wrote an autobiography about his difficult adolescence entitled Hillbilly Elegy. The book became a bestseller and was also adapted into a film. It is also interesting to note that Vance was previously a fierce critic of Trump. He called him “an idiot unfit for the presidency” and described his proposals as “immoral and absurd.” He changed his opinion of him after entering politics and is now one of Trump’s most loyal supporters. “I was wrong about Trump. He was a great president. And that’s one of the reasons why I’m working so hard to get him a second term,” Vance said in a recent interview with Fox News.

    Vance has so far presented himself as a classic conservative. For example, he is an opponent of abortion and a supporter of the so-called traditional family. However, what worries Europeans most is his stance on the war in Ukraine. The Republican senator is pushing for an end to US support for the attacked country. In the past, he has called on Ukraine to cede part of its territory to Russia in order to achieve peace, and claimed that “Ukrainian ministers are buying yachts with Western aid.”

    Strnad suspected of ties to Russia

    At the beginning of this year, Vance also came into conflict with the Czech industrial and technology holding company Czechoslovak Group (CSG) owned by businessman Michal Strnad, which supplies ammunition to Ukraine. Specifically, he opposed CSG’s plan to acquire the American ammunition manufacturer Vista Outdoor, accusing Strnad of having close ties to the Kremlin and claiming that the transaction would therefore pose a security risk to the United States.”The Czechoslovak Group has a long history of illegal activity and well-documented ties to American enemies. This transaction poses demonstrable risks to our national security,” the senator wrote in an open letter to US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen at the time. The Czech company strongly objected to his statements. “This information is unfounded and untrue,” responded Andrej Čírtek, spokesman for Strnad’s holding company. Vance later stated that he was not convinced by the Czech businessman’s arguments. Negotiations on the sale of Vista Outdoor to CSG are still ongoing.

    The election campaign team of incumbent Democratic President Biden warns against Vance as a devoted servant of Trump who will calmly “break the law” for his boss. This is an obvious reference to Trump’s former vice president, Mike Pence. After losing the 2020 election, Pence acknowledged Biden’s victory, which Trump still claims was fraudulent, and refused to support the former president’s efforts to invalidate the election results. Trump and Pence subsequently became political rivals. According to Biden’s campaign, Vance would have acted differently in the same situation.

    Like Trump, Vance is also an advocate of a tough approach towards China, supports the imposition of further sanctions and tariffs on Chinese products, and supports Israel in its war against the terrorist organization Hamas.